GENEVA — Major arms producers the United States and Russia appear set to oppose a push at a global meeting in Geneva this week to launch negotiations on legally binding rules for autonomous weapons, in what diplomats and rights groups expect to be difficult talks.
The rise of artificial intelligence has accelerated the development of drones, robots, tanks, submarines and other military hardware capable of killing without human involvement. Semi-autonomous, AI-assisted weapons have already been used in Ukraine, Sudan and the Middle East, despite mounting ethical concerns.
High-Stakes Decision in Geneva
The UN-hosted meeting starting Monday is due to decide whether to launch negotiations for a legally binding agreement on prohibitions and regulations for Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS). While most of the 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons support that step, major military powers including the US, Russia and Israel oppose it, arguing that existing humanitarian law is sufficient.
The leaders of the UN and the International Committee of the Red Cross, along with the Pope, have all warned of the dangers posed by autonomous weapons and have backed regulation.
“Machines should never be allowed to decide who lives and dies on a battlefield, but that is the dystopian reality that is fast approaching,” said Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch, which is urging the Review Conference to take firm action.
Compromise Still Possible
Two diplomats told Reuters the discussions looked set to be challenging, but states could still build bridges toward a compromise agreement by the end of the week. All options remain on the table — from a legally binding instrument to a non-binding one, or a hybrid agreement combining both elements, one diplomat added.
Campaigners warn that autonomous weapons systems can behave unpredictably, raising the risk of fatal errors. Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, a US-based nonprofit focused on reducing the risks of advanced technologies, said LAWS were no longer science fiction, pointing to media reporting of early use of fully autonomous systems in Ukraine.
Divergent Positions
Washington favours guidelines over binding rules, arguing that international law already provides a framework to govern warfare, and has proposed a five-year mandate for talks toward a non-binding agreement. The Red Cross counters that humanitarian law does not sufficiently address the specific risks posed by autonomous weapons.
Russia has not publicly stated its position going into the talks but has previously resisted proposals for a legally binding agreement. According to a senior Western diplomat, Moscow plans to block the European Union, an observer to the talks, from taking the floor.
Hehir told Reuters the US and Russia would probably seek to water down any outcome, as they did in September with a text addressing autonomous weapons and their potential for harm. The chair of this week’s talks has proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a legally binding protocol, while the UK, Germany and France propose negotiations on an instrument that leaves open whether it would be legally binding or not, Coyle said.

