A three-year-old boy living in Mandello del Lario, in northern Italy, still does not officially exist in the eyes of Italian civil authorities — the consequence of an administrative error made on his birth certificate in Paris, according to reporting by the Italian daily Corriere della Sera, cited by Ouest-France.
The names of the child’s parents were replaced on the French document by those of two other people, and for three years the family has been trying in vain to have the error corrected.
A Birth That Came Earlier Than Planned
The story begins in Paris. Although the birth was not expected for another three weeks, the expectant parents, who live in Italy, had decided to visit relatives in France. But on July 7, 2023, the baby arrived earlier than planned in the French capital. His mother, who suffered medical complications, required follow-up care for several months after the birth.
It was only after returning to Italy that the couple discovered the problem: the birth certificate drawn up in France bore the identities of two people who are not the newborn’s parents, with nationalities that also differed. The origin of the error remains unknown.
Three Years of Administrative Battle
To have their son’s birth recognized in Italy, the parents first asked the town hall of Mandello del Lario to transcribe the birth certificate into the civil registry. The municipality refused, because the information on the French document did not match their identities.
The couple then turned to the court of Lecco, without greater success. Italian justice ruled that the certificate could not be registered as it stood, but also that it could not be corrected, since it had been issued abroad.
The case eventually reached the Court of Appeal in Milan, which offered the family two options: launch a rectification procedure in France, or bring legal action in Italy to formally establish the child’s parentage. The parents chose the second route.
Consequences Beyond Paperwork
The lack of official recognition extends well beyond documents. It also complicates procedures such as enrolling the boy in nursery school and his access to healthcare.
- The birth certificate was issued in Paris in July 2023.
- The names recorded belong to two other people, of different nationalities.
- Italian courts say the document cannot be registered or corrected as it stands.
- The family is now pursuing a parentage case in Italy.

