Could the United States change the way it elects its president as early as 2028? The results of the recent midterm elections, marked by a Democratic wave, have reignited a debate that is two decades old—and one that resurfaces regularly in the national conversation.
Now bolstered by several governorships and legislative majorities in multiple states, Democrats could advance an agreement that would see the American president elected directly by the national popular vote, rather than by electors representing each state.
How the Electoral College Works
To understand what is at stake, it helps to recall that in US presidential elections, citizens currently vote to designate an electoral college rather than the head of state directly. Americans cast ballots for electors affiliated with one candidate or another, who are then tasked with formally choosing the president. Barring extremely rare errors or deliberate deception, electors vote systematically for the candidate they supported.
Each state has as many electors as it has representatives in the House (a number determined by population) and senators (two for every state). In the vast majority of states, the candidate who finishes first wins all of those electors—even if they lead their opponent by only a few hundred votes. This is the well-known “winner takes all” rule. A very small number of states use a degree of proportionality, producing an outcome more reflective of the detailed vote.
This system can produce a paradoxical result: winning the national popular vote does not guarantee access to the White House. That happened in 2000, when Al Gore was defeated by George W. Bush despite nearly 500,000 more votes nationwide, and again in 2016, when Donald Trump beat Hillary Clinton despite nearly three million fewer votes.
An Agreement Among States to Bypass the System
It is precisely this mechanism that the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact seeks to change. Launched in 2006, the proposed interstate agreement rests on a simple idea: participating states commit to awarding all their electors to the candidate who wins the national popular vote, rather than to the candidate who wins their own state.
The Electoral College would therefore not be officially abolished. But its operation would be profoundly transformed: the candidate who wins the most votes nationwide would mechanically secure a majority of electors, even if those electors had been chosen to represent another candidate.
The project works on one condition: that the signatory states represent at least 270 electors—a majority of the Electoral College, and thus the number of votes needed to be elected president. To date, eighteen Democrat-led states plus the District of Columbia have ratified the pact, representing 222 electoral votes.
The midterm results could change the equation. Democrats took control of both local legislative chambers and the governor’s office in five strategic states: Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Arizona. If all of them joined the pact, that would push the total past the 270-vote threshold. According to Axios, they could even bring the total to 283 electors.
A Goal Still Far From Certain
Do the midterms therefore amount to a green light for adopting this long-debated agreement? Not necessarily. “It is difficult to know whether (Democratic) legislators will prioritize adopting this agreement,” the New York Times writes, recalling that the campaign was dominated “by other concerns, such as reducing high costs and imposing guardrails on the Trump administration.”
In 2019, for example, Nevada’s Democratic governor vetoed an attempt to join, arguing that the initiative risked reducing the influence of small states. Conversely, some are already voicing support: “I think the national popular vote is a logical solution,” Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro stressed on Saturday, now with more potential allies to reopen discussions.
If enough states join the agreement, it could theoretically take effect as early as the next presidential election, in 2028. But in theory only, since the project would undoubtedly face challenges. “It is almost certain to face legal challenges from conservative groups,” the AP news agency notes, adding that such challenges could delay or even prevent its implementation.

