France’s Council of State on Saturday upheld a police decision to bar the inter-union protest in Paris from following its planned route between Bastille and Nation, siding with the Paris police prefecture and forcing demonstrators onto a circuit between Porte de Bagnolet and Porte de Charenton.
The ruling aligns with President Emmanuel Macron’s stated wish, expressed earlier in the week, to keep demonstrations out of city centres following the violence that erupted on 17 October.
Unions Decry ‘Strategy of Disorganisation’
Union leaders condemned the decision. “The Council of State is validating the strategy of disorganisation pursued by the Interior Ministry and the police prefecture. It is very worrying,” Adèle Tellez, co-secretary of the CGT in Paris, told BFM. She nonetheless urged demonstrators to respect the ruling and gather at Porte de Bagnolet.
The decision followed a day of legal back-and-forth. The police prefecture had banned the unions’ central Paris route, and separately cancelled the planned Yellow Vest procession between Bastille and Concorde. Authorities argued the routes were incompatible with public order because of the density of police stations, bank branches, shops and fast-food outlets along them.
Administrative Court Had Suspended Ban
In a dramatic twist later on Friday, the administrative court suspended the ban, finding that prefect Patrice Faure “provides no numerical evidence capable of establishing the impossibility or difficulty of policing a disputed gathering with a previously defined route.” The court acknowledged “the real risk of public order disturbances resulting from the tense social context of recent weeks” but ruled that organisers were entitled to argue the order represented “a serious and manifestly illegal infringement of the freedom to demonstrate.”
“We won,” declared UNEF and the CGT, two of the organising bodies. Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez swiftly announced an appeal, citing the events of 17 October. He ultimately prevailed.
The previous week’s Paris demonstration was likewise rerouted from Porte d’Italie to Porte de Vincennes, again with the aim of keeping protesters away from city centres.
350 Actions Nationwide
A police source said 350 actions capable of mobilising between 350,000 and 450,000 people in total had been recorded for Saturday. Another police source described a “pre-insurrectional climate” in comments to AFP.
A new curfew has been imposed in certain districts of Paris for the nights of Saturday to Sunday and Sunday to Monday, from 11pm to 6am — a measure increasingly adopted in several French cities in recent days.
Mixed Picture Across France
- Bordeaux: Unlike the previous week, the prefecture authorised the procession but anticipates a “difficult” day and “violent actions.” City hall criticised a route “too close to the city centre.”
- Lyon: The prefecture approved a march outside the central district, which still bears the scars of the 17 October violence, when a tourism office building was set on fire.
- Marseille: Only “declared” gatherings will be permitted.
- Rennes: A demonstration initially banned was authorised after organisers modified the route.
The Interior Ministry’s entourage has expressed concern over the use of the words “revolution” and “insurrection” on social media, particularly as Halloween approaches. “The pretext of Halloween night will not be a legitimate reason to conceal one’s face in public space” in order to “commit public order disturbances,” Nuñez warned.

